Value Creation in the Premier League Transfer Market

Introduction
Every football fan has an opinion on which clubs buy well. Brighton, Brentford and Bournemouth have built reputations for finding players nobody else has spotted and selling them on for a large profit. Chelsea has spent close to £2bn on players in five years. And Manchester United seem to have a gift for signing big names who never quite deliver.
In this blog we test these assumptions, and set out to answer the question of which clubs are creating value, and which are losing it? Has each squad grown in value by more or less than the club has spent and which individual deals are driven this.
Over the last five seasons, Premier League clubs have spent £14.6bn on players (of which around £1.6bn went on agent fees and the Premier League levy) and recouped £7.0bn from sales. That is £7.6bn of net spend. Over the same period, the combined estimated market value of the 20 squads rose by just £4.3bn.
Put simply, the league as a whole has paid £3.3bn more for its players than they are now worth. That gap is not spread evenly. Some clubs turn every pound spent into more than a pound of squad value. Others spend heavily and end up with a squad worth less than the money put in.
Why is this important? Squad value is a club's main asset, the source of future sale profits, and an increasingly important lever under the Premier League and UEFA's squad cost rules. A club that keeps losing value has to keep spending just to stand still.
Value is however only half the story, and every club should be assessed alongside what happened on the pitch. Arsenal have lost £283.5m of value over the period yet built a squad that finished second three times and won the title in 2025/26.
Methodology
We take each club's squad market value at the end of 2020/21 as the starting point. We then add everything spent on players, less income received from sales, from 2021/22 to 2025/26. That gives what the squad would be worth if every pound of net spend simply held its value. We compare this with the actual squad market value at the 2025/26 year end to derive a squad value added. A positive figure means the squad has grown in value by more than the money put in. A negative figure means value has been lost.
Market values are primarily from Transfermarkt, and replaced by the actual sale fee where a player has been sold. Market value is an estimate, not a price.
Net spend comes from published club accounts. The figures include our estimates for 2025/26 for all clubs except Manchester United who have published their accounts.
Player acquisition costs include a 4% Premier League levy and, we estimate, around 8% in agent fees. This means a player theoretically loses around 12% of his value before he has kicked a ball.
Key findings
Only six of the 20 clubs have added value since 2020/21. The other 14 have spent more on players than their squads have gained in value, and the biggest spenders have lost the most.
Brighton are in a league of their own. The squad has grown from £246.5m to £576.5m while the club has been a net seller by £15.5m. That is £345.5m of value added, more than double anyone else.
Manchester United are at the other end. They have lost £809.0m of value, the most in the league, spending £856.2m net for a squad worth just £47.2m more than five years ago.
£1.1bn gap between Brighton and United. From Brighton at +£345.5m to United at −£809.0m, the gap between the best and worst is more than £1.1bn. Yet on the pitch there is little between them: United have averaged 61 points a season, Brighton 55.
Most promoted clubs that stay up create value. Nottingham Forest (+£161.5m), Sunderland (+£159.7m), Brentford (+£129.7m) and Bournemouth (+£87.6m) complete the top five. They have generally bought young, relatively inexpensive players and when necessary, sold at the right time.
Relegation hurts. Clubs that have suffered relegation have all lost value: Fulham (−£148.2m), Leeds (−£115.5m) and Burnley (−£27.8m).
Value for money is what counts. Liverpool and Chelsea have lost almost exactly the same amount, £677m each. Liverpool turned it into 385 points and a title; Chelsea managed 302 points and none. Arsenal lost less than half as much (−£283.5m) and won 401 points and a title, while Spurs lost £641.2m for 276 points, just one more than Brighton. Manchester City (−£88.7m) are the exception, though given everything currently surrounding the club, their figures are probably best left alone.
The value creators don't rely on their academies. The six clubs that added the most squad value — Brighton, Brentford, Sunderland, Bournemouth, Forest and Palace — buy young, inexpensive players and develop them. Their signings have generated +£990m of value, three times what their academies produced.
The others often do the opposite. They buy players closer to their peak, who then largely lose value, while using their academies to help offset those losses.
The best deals of the period. Erling Haaland: £57.3m all-in cost, now worth £173.9m (+£116.6m). Morgan Rogers at Villa runs him close, adding £108.0m of value on an all-in cost of just £9.0m.
The biggest value drops are recent. Measured by value lost per year, Alexander Isak at Liverpool tops the list: bought for £125.0m, now worth £73.9m, a loss of £51.1m in his first season. Wissa (−£28.3m a year) and Elanga (−£24.2m) at Newcastle follow.
Lost value is someone else's gain. Over the period, the Big Six paid £2.46bn for 48 players from other Premier League clubs: Isak to Liverpool (£125m), Rogers to Chelsea (£117m), Anderson to City (£116m), Rice to Arsenal (£105m) and Caicedo to Chelsea (£100m).
Club by Club Dashboard
The dashboard below looks at the detail behind each club. Select a club to see the detail behind its numbers, including the deals that have driven the change in squad value.
Sources and Conventions
The analysis is based on the 20 clubs competing in the Premier League in 2025/26.
Market values are primarily from Transfermarkt, converted at €1.15 to £1, and replaced by the actual sale fee where a player has been sold. Market value is an estimate, not a price. It is the best consistent yardstick across 20 squads, but it is not necessarily what a buyer would pay tomorrow.
Squad market values include players loaned out to other clubs but exclude players loaned in.
Net spend comes from published club accounts and includes agent fees, levies and add-ons. The figures include our estimates for 2025/26 for all clubs except Manchester United, who have already published their accounts. Summer 2026 trading is excluded unless it falls within the club's 2025/26 financial year.
Player-level purchase and sale fees are the initial fees widely reported and exclude future add-ons





Comments